Cedar Shake Vs Composite Roofing: A Smarter Alternative

When comparing cedar shake vs composite roofing, Brava offers a smarter, longer-lasting solution. Our composite shake shingles provide the authentic look of natural cedar with unmatched durability, minimal maintenance, and eco-friendly materials—without the common issues of real wood.


Cedar Shake vs Composite: Classic Charm or Smarter Performance?

Natural Cedar Shake Roofing: Timeless Look, Not-So-Timeless Performance

When comparing cedar shake vs composite roofing, it’s clear that while natural cedar offers rustic appeal, it falls short in longevity and sustainability. Traditional cedar shakes—made from red cedar or other aged woods—bring a classic look but carry serious disadvantages:

  • Environmental Impact – Harvesting cedar contributes to deforestation and is increasingly restricted.

  • Fire Hazard – Due to high flammability, many states and municipalities have banned wood shake roofs.

  • High Maintenance – Cedar shakes require frequent treatments to prevent mold, rot, moss, and insect damage.

  • Short Lifespan – Even with proper care, natural cedar roofs typically last just 15–20 years.

Brava Composite Shake Roofing: Innovation Without Compromise

In the cedar shake vs composite comparison, Brava composite shake stands out as the smart, long-lasting solution. Designed to replicate the authentic look of hand-split cedar, Brava shakes go beyond tradition with modern performance:

  • Made from 95% recycled materials and fully recyclable for eco-conscious building.

  • Offered in 5″, 7″, and 12″ widths with varied thicknesses (⅝” to ⅞”) for natural texture and shadow lines.

  • Available in a broad selection of factory-blended or custom colors to match any architectural style.

  • Rated Class A or C for fire resistance and Class 4 for impact resistance.

  • Requires no ongoing maintenance and backed by a 50-year limited warranty.


Cedar Shake vs Composite: Side-by-Side Performance

Feature Brava Composite Shake Natural Cedar Shake
Authentic Look
Fire Rating Class A or C Varies, needs treatment
Impact Rating Class 4
Maintenance-Free
Freeze/Thaw Resistance
Lifespan 50+ years 15–20 years
Eco-Friendly
Color-Fast
Installation Easy, no special tools Labor-intensive
Hail Warranty

Why Brava Composite Shake Is the Better Choice

  • Durability: Virtually unbreakable and withstands extreme weather.

  • Sustainability: Reduces environmental impact with recycled content.

  • Curb Appeal: Matches or exceeds the look of real cedar.

  • Peace of Mind: Approved for use in strict jurisdictions like California and Colorado.

  • Cost Efficiency: Less maintenance and fewer repairs over time.


Available Colors for Brava Composite Shake

Choose from popular shades or request a custom blend:

  • Aged Cedar

  • Weathered Cedar

  • Rustic Cedar

  • Charcoal Cedar

  • Natural Cedar

  • Custom Color Options


Conclusion: Choose Brava for Beauty, Safety, and Longevity

When comparing cedar shake vs composite roofing, Brava comes out on top. It delivers the rustic appeal of cedar without the risks, costs, or environmental harm. If you want a roof that lasts for decades, looks amazing, and supports sustainability, Brava composite shake is your best choice.